As for Luhrmann's reputation for excess: Well, he certainly visualizes Gatsby's parties as excess, but they are supposed to be excessive, excessive materialism is part of the point of the story. Luhrmann tells us it is from a sanitarium where Nick is drying out from excessive alcoholism. Luhrmann and co-writer Craig Pearse stay pretty close to the text with a few additions and devices, most notably, to those of us who read the book, know that it is Nick Caraway (Tobey Maguire) who tells the story, and is a firsthand witness to all the events, but we never knew from where he tells the story. Mia Farrow played Daisy as an airhead and a dingbat, but Mulligan gives Daisy a bit more spine, and fashions a character that has a pretty good idea where her self-interests lay. For all the time that Gatsby spends trying to prove he is good enough for Daisy, the audience, for the book or the film, is led down the path that she is not good enough for him. When Tom espouses his vile racial philosophies one might think that someday he might actually do something about it. Bruce Dern played Tom as a kind of loopy (Dern's specialty) racial conspiracy nut, but Edgerton gives Tom a much harder edge. He has status and wealth because he's supposed to have status and wealth, and he's not about to give up all that, and certainly not his wife, to this new money usurper Gatsby, without a fight. Tom is as rich, maybe even richer than Gatsby, but his money is old, he is an aristocrat with a deep sense of entitlement. He and Daisy were married when Daisy could no longer wait for Gatsby to prove himself worthy of her. Tom Buchanan (Joel Edgerton) is Gatsby's antagonist. This is not a shining white knight rescuing a damsel in distress this is a bare knuckles brawl for the hand of Daisy, and she is going to have to choose. This decision (both DeCaprio's and Luhrmann's) to take Gatsby down from some ethereal literary icon into a flesh and blood human being gives the movie an intensity that the 1974 version and most of the literary criticism of the book that I have ever read, never perceived. For myself, it is DeCaprio's best and most powerful performance. He has a plan and he is going to execute it and as far as he is concerned, for all the right reasons. DeCaprio's Gatsby is forceful, decisive he is a determined man of significant accomplishment and great ability. Redford's Gatsby seemed reticent and insecure about his past regretful that he must live a lie in order to accomplish his goal. Leo DeCaprio is the only actor of this generation that could play Gatsby, just as Robert Redford could only play Gatsby the previous generation. He is going to win her back and make things as they should have been. Daisy was Gatsby's great love, but he lost her, and now in one final herculean effort he is going to correct his past this one last time. No, he did everything, and I mean everything, for the love of a woman. But it is not for them that Gatsby has made this remarkable metamorphosis. This belief, that he can change his past, to correct it as it were, has given him a veneer of respectability that has put him in good stead with his underworld connections. He has acquired his fabulous wealth through bootlegging and stock swindles. Unlike Alger's heroes, he has not followed the straight and narrow. He is the American success myth both personified and perverted. He is the self made American man in every way. In true Horatio Alger tradition he has worked hard to improve himself, but when his past creeps up on him and threatens his well crafted self image, he suavely and effortlessly changes it, his past, and he inhabits the change until it becomes the reality. Jay Gatsby has achieved success in a fashion beyond most imaginations, excepting his own. Especially this Aussie, Baz Luhrmann, who is known to overload, over-hype and overcook his theatrical product into a glittery miasma of small meaning and little consequence. How dare some Aussie come over here and tell us about the meaning of one of the great works of American literature. THE GREAT GATSBY There is no movie I have been more prepared to dislike than this one.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |